I had a few people insist that you must remove all the other spark plugs when doing a compression test on one cylinder. One guy even shrilly exclaimed he was sure that you couldn't get any reading at all, unless all the other plugs were removed first. I think he had some kind of emotional issues, I dunno.
There was no technical reason given, which is suspicious in itself, but I think their concept might be that if the other cylinders are sucking air out of the plenum, you might not read a true value for the cylinder with the gauge on it. The plenum is certainly less than atmospheric at idle, but while bumping it over at very low RPM with a button, it still just isn't a freaking Hoover vacuum in there. It just isn't turning fast enough, long enough, to draw down the plenum much below atmospheric with just a few revs. Seemed a little unlikely to me.
So I tried it both ways, and found that it makes almost no difference. Anybody else notice the same thing? Or maybe the opposite?
Maybe if the plenum was very small, as it may be on some cars, then possibly you might notice a difference in compression readings on one cylinder, between all-other-plugs-in, verses all-other-plugs-out. But I think that with the Gen2 plenum, there is so much air volume in there, that after cranking it over for a few revs, or enough to get a good reading, the other cylinders haven't depleted the plenum of air to any noticeable degree. Even with the throttle closed,
some air still gets sucked in. Otherwise the car would choke and stall when you release the throttle, right? (Of Course!)
Removing all-other-plugs seems like a good practice, but without much real effect in our case, at least thats what I found. Contrary experience?
Any thoughts on this?
(other than "Thats just the way its done", or "Thats the way we always done it")!!
